Jimmy and Gretchen adjust to life after saying I love you. Edgar and Dorothy have sexual problems. Lindsay and Paul start a new hobby.
- Chris Geere as Jimmy Shive-Overly
- Aya Cash as Gretchen Cutler
- Desmin Borges as Edgar Quintero
- Kether Donohue as Lindsay Jillian
Jimmy and Gretchen reach new heights in the bedroom but Jimmy refuses to acknowledge saying "I love you", or meaning it if he did.
Edgar is having sexual performance issues due to his new medication. Jimmy suggests role playing.
Paul shows Lindsay that he is giving up all his hobbies and throwing out his stuff, vowing to only pursue things they can do together.
Sam and his wingmen want a surprise reunion show with "under the radar" publicity. Jimmy begins to find out things he never knew about Gretchen; she went to Bible camp and she speaks fluent Spanish.
Edgar opens up to Dorothy and they agree to work it out; Edgar decides to ditch his medication.
Sam's show is a disaster as nobody shows up; Gretchen didn't understand the concept of under the radar publicity, so there was no publicity at all. To save face, Gretchen addresses the congregation of a storefront Hispanic church, in Spanish, and gets them to attend.
She tells Jimmy it doesn't matter about saying "I love you" because she always has one foot out the door anyway. He says "I love you".
Paul is creating a "domestic paradise" for Lindsay with pre-planned, pre-portioned gourmet meals. After cutting up some vegetables, she stabs him with her kitchen knife.